Though I’ve been heavily debating which recipe to share with you next, the wonderful crispness in the morning air made it nearly impossible for me to resist sharing this wonderful one with you.

As I’ve told you before, this beautiful season, we have been blessed with as many pears as we can possible handle. We’ve been canning & dehydrating like madmen!

I use the term “we” loosely, and by loosely, I mean I use “we” to mean “me” (as Stuart has yet to share in my preserving enthusiasm). “All by myself… don’t wanna be… all by myself… anymore…”

Anyway. For the past few years, I’ve been wanting to make pear butter, yet for one reason or another, had never gotten around to it.

Well this year, I did. And oh, am I so glad.

A few nights ago, Georgia and I ventured into the orchard with buckets in hand. I filled the buckets completely with fruit that had fallen on the ground, specifically choosing the pears that were very ripe. Bruises? Sure! Rotting spots? You bet! Mush on half of it? I’ll take it!

You see, the beauty of pear butter is that you don’t have to use your beautiful pears to make it. In fact, the more ripe the fruit, the sweeter the overall butter will be at the end. So use this recipe to utilize all of those past-prime & less-than-gorgeous pears you’ve happened across this season.

Side-note: This recipe is a “low-sugar recipe”, meaning I am mostly relying on the sweetness of the fruit for my sugar. I can’t stand preserve recipes that are 50% fruit and 50% sugar! Yikes! Instead, I chose to opt for a recipe that would utilize all the goodness already in the ‘ol pear and one that is simply enhanced by the addition of a natural sweetener.

Okay. Enough jabbering. Let’s party.

How to Make Pear Butter

You will need:
 – 3 lbs. of overly ripe pears
 – 2 teaspoons of lemon juice (optional)
 – 1/4 cup rapadura or honey
 – 1 cinnamon stick
 – 5 cloves
 – 5 allspice berries
 – 1 tsp. vanilla extract or 1 vanilla bean

Step One: Clean the pears up. Give them a water wash, and using a paring knife, cut out all of the rotten spots and such. Bruises are really no big deal…but we don’t want anythin’ too grody in here. Be sure to remove the stem and core too.

Step Two: While I sure wish I had a wonderful food mill (like this one) to run these pears through, I didn’t. But what I did have is a food processor (like this), though I think a blender would work wonders here too! I simple put a load of pears into the food processor and pureed them until they were nice and smooth! Sometimes, I had to stop it to scrape the sides of the bowl, then re-run for a few more seconds in order to get all the chunks. The overall goal of this step is simple: Puree the pears by any means necessary. Something tells me you’re inventive enough to figure out the “how”…

Step Three: After the pears are pureed, mix in the lemon juice, sugar or honey, vanilla, and spices. Mmm. Then, pour the pears into a 9 x 13 pan (or two!).

Did someone say fall?

Step Four: Bake the pears in a 300 degree oven for 2-3 hours, stirring every 30 minutes or so. The longer you cook the pears, the thicker the resulting butter will be. I left mine in for 2.5 hours, and was pleased with the overall thickness at the end.

Step Five: Once the pears are thickened to your liking, remove them from the oven. Then carefully remove the cinnamon sticks, allspice berries, and cloves.

Step Six: Try to not stick your face in the pan and lap this pear butter up like a thirsty dog. Trust me, you’ll want to. It made my house smell like a fall-fairy had come to party. It. Was. Amazing.

Step Seven: Okay. Now, you can either store this in your refrigerator (it will last for about a month and a half…) OR you can do what I did and can it! Simply ladle the pear butter into sterilized half-pint, pint, or quart jars, adjust your two-piece lids on, and process in a water-canner for 10 minutes. Though I won’t elaborate on the details, make sure you follow all the canning-protocol to ensure success!


Note: This recipe is easily doubled or tripled to your delight. I tripled it. Because that’s how I roll.

And that’s all folks.

Pear butter a la ice cream.

Pear butter a la toast.

Pear butter a la biscuit.

Pear butter a la oatmeal.

Every single morsel of this wonderful preserve shrieks of the goodness of fall. And though I am still sad to see summer fading, smelling this wonderful treat makes me eagerly anticipate all the goodness that fall brings with it.

Like applesauce. And football games. And sweatshirts. And pumpkins.

Mmm! I can hardly wait!

But until then, I must keep busy with my task at hand: Survive summer harvest.

If you don’t hear from me for the next few weeks…send help!

For other great meal ideas, no matter what your dietary restrictions, check out the meal planning service I use: Real Plans.

Essential Fall Recipes Ebook

I’ve put together a fresh printable of a few of my favorite new fall recipes for you to enjoy in your own kitchen. They’re easily adaptable based on your family’s needs and your garden’s offerings.

Download the FREE ebook: